This was a very good script and very well done, but I think the premise is just a little to close to What Dreams May Come. In both movies, the protagonist fights his way through hell with a trusty side kick to rescue someone he loves. You take it the comedic route and maybe that's enough to differentiate.
First, I think I only found two kinda sorta typos:
pg 5. add I in "I wore this yesterday didn't ?" maybe on purpose cause will interrupts
pg 55. celtx double space error, last line. If you are using celtx, the double space after the period in "You murdered an entire family." throws family to the next line when it could easily fit on the first.
Now on with the meaty parts of the review. I was a little thrown that Will and Sara were brother and sister and not married, but I think you chose correctly. If Sara was a jesus freak and Will an athiest, that marriage would be difficult. You'd also be one step closer to the previous movie. I made a note about this as I was reading, but after further thought, you went the right way.
I felt the setup for the quest could use a little work. God just tells him, "This is what you have to do to get her. Here's a sidekick." But now that I think of this one, you couldn't pick a better spot for a deus ex machina. I'm going to debunk my whole review. I would have liked a less expository way for Will to figure out what he has to do for his quest.
I had some reservations about Chad, let's see if I can't talk myself out of those. We do get a bit of his motivation, that he wants to give something back, but he's putting eternity on the line for very little. God says help Will so he does, but why not give him his own reasons for trying to get into hell... say goodbye to someone, say he's sorry, punch a guy in the face for killing him. I don't know. Seems odd to be so eager to risk eternity in hell for being spared an eternity in hell.
Easy question, why go up the circles of hell? I always thought they got deeper. Do they go up in the divine comedy and I forgot that?
And finally, how exactly did Will help speed things up in Purgatory? I assume he just used his anal-IRS background, but you might want to make it more clear.
The last thing is the humor. I think you could improve things in a lot of places, but there were no groaners for me. Also, I actually laughed out loud at the 8th circle. Overall, good job, but I'd be worried about how close the general premise is to that other movie.
Review
I've been to the 8th circle
Review ID: 2805274
Reviews of Through Hell, For Sara (v5) (60)
Through Hell for Sara but heaven to read.
Review of: Through Hell, For Sara (v5)
on: 11/19/2009
[more]
Review of: Through Hell, For Sara (v5)
on: 11/19/2009
[more]
Reviews by Mike Souder (6)
No Athiest Joke, I'm Offended
Review of: The International Olympic Messiah Competition
on: 11/14/2009
[more]
Review of: The International Olympic Messiah Competition
on: 11/14/2009
[more]
How it Rates
Details
Uploaded by: dbenamor
Synopsis: An atheist and his missionary sister are killed in a car accident, the atheist ascends to Heaven and is surprised to discover his sister has been damned to Hell due to a "processing error". He must literally go through Hell to get her back.
Format: PDF
Length: 96 pages
Uploaded on: 2008-12-04 19:45:47
Genre: Adventure, Comedy
Bio: I've written 10 complete screenplays and co-written two. I have a B.A. in Psychology and Film Writing and Analysis. I was in the top 100 of the most recent Scriptapalooza features comp with "Inside". I was named one of seven finalists for the Script Magazine Scholarship to the Vancouver Film
[more]
Trigger Updates
You know, we never get tired of saying it: yet another TriggerStreet.com screenplay submission has...
[more]
Earn credits to get reviews of your comic books! You can now request to be...
[more]
Yet another TriggerStreet.com screenplay submission has been recognized with a consider from professional script coverage...
[more]


