Samarkand seemed like one very long chase scene with lots of its dialogue ending with exclamation marks!!! Everything was always on one very intense level!
I was taught by a writing instructor years ago to choose scenes carefully – not just to introduce characters, but to move the story along and gain reader’s interest as well. So if you have one fight scene after another, it all becomes very boring very quickly.
Instead, we need moments of normal, then moments of strange, then some FEAR! And then some normal again as our characters try to understand where they are and how they got there. We must also have scenes that explore who the characters are and what they want to achieve.
For a story like this, the most important question, however, is WHY the kids are there. This mystery/problem needs to be stated early so there is a direction to the story.
There are a lot of characters in Samarkand and they all seem to speak with the same “voice”. I couldn’t tell Tommy’s words from Peter’s or James’. I couldn’t tell the girls apart either. And if I covered up ALL the character’s names and just read the dialogue, I would not have been able to tell the difference between ANY of them.
Each character needs a different way of speaking and a different purpose for being in the story. Each character needs to grow and learn something (except the bad guys) by the end. So you may want to limit the number of characters you work with until you are comfortable manipulating lots of people through a story.
Some of the dialogue and action were unclear: Page 41) SARAH: “The fresco. “O-2-7”... That’s it, the first sign! “The battle of Oa” but only the O is capitalized, and take notice of the angel in the upper corner, he’s pointing at something-- a bookshelf!” What?
You obviously have a very clear mental picture of this story. At this point, it is just very, very hard to follow.
Review
Seeking Samarkand review
Review ID: 2766842
Reviews of Seeking Samarkand (8)
Reviews by Janet712 (34)
How it Rates
Details
Uploaded by: fcagno
Synopsis: A group of misfit kids from post-Katrina New Orleans gets magically transported to another world and then embarks on a quest to find the mysterious city of Samarkand and hopefully the means to return home. Along the way, they battle crooked knights and squabble with one another.
Format: PDF
Length: 125 pages
Uploaded on: 2009-10-14 17:01:05
Genre: Adventure, Children/Family, Sci-Fi/Fantasy
Bio: Why did I go to film school again? Well... now I'm stuck with being an aspiring filmmaker... Life could be a hell lot worse!
[more]
Trigger Updates
You know, we never get tired of saying it: yet another TriggerStreet.com screenplay submission has...
[more]
Earn credits to get reviews of your comic books! You can now request to be...
[more]
Yet another TriggerStreet.com screenplay submission has been recognized with a consider from professional script coverage...
[more]


